My question is with reference to Verse #173 of Sura #2. What is the implication of
the words, " wamaa uhilla bihi lighairillah", therein? Do these words prohibit me
from accepting or eating any food article (not necessarily of animals slaughtered in
names other than of Allah) which are offered here in India, after Fatehakhani done in
the names of saintly persons like Abdul Qadar Jeelani?
The meaning of the Quranic Verse: "Forbidden to you (for food) are: ..., and that on which has
been invoked the name of other than Allah,..." (Al-Baqarah, or the heifer, V173)
Praise be to Allah,
Ibn Kathir (May Allah have mercy on him) said in explanation of the above Verse:
"..that on which has been invoked the name of other than Allah,..." means slaughtered animals
on which has been invoked a name other than the name of Allah; such as an idol, an antagonist,
an arrow of divination and the like for which Arabs of pre-Islamic periods slaughtered animals.
In explanation of Verse 3 of Surat al-Ma’ida, or the table, Ibn Kathir said: "The Verse: "..., and
that on which has been invoked the name of other than Allah,..." means that eating of animal
food on which, upon slaughtering a name other than Allah is invoked is forbidden because Allah,
the Exalted, prescribed that His Great Name be invoked upon slaughtering any of His creatures. It
is the unanimous opinion that one is forbidden to select to invoke a name of an idol of any
creature upon slaughtering an animal.
In explanation of the Verse "... that which is sacrificed on stone (altars)...", Mujahid and Ibn
Jurayj said: Those were stones (altars) put around the Ka’bah. Ibn Jurayj said: There were 360
stones (altars) at which pre-Islamic Arabs used to slaughter animal ... They would grill meat and
put it on these stones.. Allah forbade such act and disallowed eating of such meat even if the
name of Allah is invoked on it. Slaughtering of animal at stones (altars) is part of polytheism,
which is prohibited by Allah and His Messenger. Comparison should be made to the foregoing to
decide the rule for slaughtering of animals on which is invoked other than the name of Allah.
All slaughtered animals on which a name other than the name of Allah; such is the name of a
prophet, a holy man, an idol, the devil, or an item of worship such as the cross and the like may
not be eaten.